The 'You're a Good Man Arthur Morgan' meme originates from the critically acclaimed video game Red Dead Redemption 2, specifically during a poignant conversation between the protagonist, Arthur Morgan, and Sister Calderón at a train station. In the scene, Arthur expresses his fears and regrets about his life of crime, to which the Sister responds with deep empathy, validating his inherent goodness. While the original moment is profoundly emotional and central to Arthur’s redemption arc, internet culture has adapted the scene for both sincere appreciation and self-deprecating irony. It is frequently used to hyperbolize small, everyday acts of kindness or to mock the feeling of moral superiority one feels after performing a single, insignificant good deed.