The 'John Silver Explaining to Anna Jay' meme originates from an episode of AEW's 'Being The Elite' YouTube series, featuring Dark Order members John Silver and Anna Jay. In the scene, Silver is seen yelling enthusiastically and gesturing wildly while Anna Jay stands by with a deadpan, unimpressed expression. This contrast perfectly mirrors the 'Bro Explaining' or 'Guy Explaining to Girl' meme format, making it a favorite for depicting obsessive fans or people who don't realize their audience is disinterested. Since its debut in late 2020, it has transitioned from wrestling circles to mainstream social media, used to mock niche obsessions, lore dumps, and one-sided conversations.