The Anthony Fantano Michelleyroo memes are deeply rooted in the lore of 'The Needle Drop,' the internet's most prominent music review channel. Featuring nostalgic or candid photos of Anthony Fantano and his past associations, these images became a staple in music-focused internet circles like /mu/ and Reddit. Fans use these templates to satirize the critic’s early career, his hyper-specific rating system, and his influence over music trends. The meme captures a specific era of internet music culture, often used to express the feeling of finding a 'strong 10' or to mock the elitism often found in record-collecting communities.