Neopets memes tap into the deep-seated nostalgia of the early internet era, often revolving around the guilt of neglecting virtual pets for decades. Originating from the massive popularity of Neopets.com in the early 2000s, these memes typically focus on themes like the broken site economy, the absurdity of specific items like the 'Giant Omelette,' or the shock of returning to a 'dying' pet after fifteen years away. As the original user base aged, the humor shifted from simple fan appreciation to ironic commentary on the site's longevity and the collective childhood experience of millions who once obsessed over Paint Brushes, Codestones, and Faerie Quests.